Two potential problems about Dynare and the Reference Manual

My version is 4.4.3

  1. It is said in page 63 of Reference Manual:
    “After estimation with Metropolis iterations (option mh_replic > 0 or option load_mh_file set) the parameters M_.params and the variance matrix M_.Sigma_e of the shocks are set to the posterior mean.”

No. I use the following command:
estimation(datafile=mydata_datafab_lev,mode_compute=4,mh_replic=2000,mh_nblocks=2,mh_drop=0.45,mh_jscale=0.6);
But “M_.params” just stores the mode.
This may lead to another problem. That is, if I try to plot IRFs by adding the following command:
stoch_simul(conditional_variance_decomposition=[1 2 4 8 16]) c i y lab u ele w GR pi;
It is in fact the mode of the parameters used. I compare this plot and that generated by a model given parameter values as the posterior mean, there are different. However, if I let the parameter values as the posterior mode, they are the same.

  1. About historical and smothed variables

I estimate a model without measurement errors and stochastic singularity with the following command:

varobs y_obs i_obs pi_obs;
estimation(datafile=mydata_datafab_lev,mode_compute=6,mh_replic=10000,mh_nblocks=2,mh_drop=0.45,mh_jscale=0.6,moments_varendo,selected_variables_only,conditional_variance_decomposition=[1 2 4 8 16]);

A problem arises: Historical series of pi_obs is far different from its smoothed series.
The two become the same if I delete the last three options in the estimation block and use the following command:
estimation(datafile=mydata_datafab_lev,mode_compute=6,mh_replic=10000,mh_nblocks=2,mh_drop=0.45,mh_jscale=0.6)

  1. This is a known bug that has been fixed in the unstable version: dynare.org/DynareWiki/KnownBugs
  2. Could you please try the unstable version, see whether the problem persists, and then report back. If it persists, please send me the files, e.g. via email.

Hi, Johannes. The problem does not persist to the unstable version.

[quote=“jpfeifer”]1. This is a known bug that has been fixed in the unstable version: dynare.org/DynareWiki/KnownBugs
2. Could you please try the unstable version, see whether the problem persists, and then report back. If it persists, please send me the files, e.g. via email.[/quote]