Comparing IRFs of DSGE and DSGE-VAR in dynare

Estimation DSGE-VAR
1

Dear Johannes,

As I understand it, the ‘bvar_irf’ option used under DSGE-VAR estimation in dynare produces figures that compare the IRFs of the DSGE model (solid line) and those of the DSGE-VAR(lambda) (the dotted lines)… I was wondering if there is any way we can know the EQUATIONS producing them?

I understand that the IRFs can be produced with the state-space representation of the DSGE model (using .ghx and .ghu) and I managed to retrieved the solid line. But how can I manually compute the IRFs of the DSGE-VAR(lambda), i.e., any of the solid lines? Put differently, does dynare provide a way that allows users to do simulation or forecast using the estimated DSGE-VAR(lambda)?

I have searched through the forum and manual but I could find little information about using the DSGE-VAR(lambda) model and its posterior estimates, though there are quite a few papers out there where people compare the forecast ability of DSGE-VARs and DSGE model etc… Am i misunderstanding something here? (Assuming they also use dnare), how do they get the forecasts then, say, from a DSGE-VAR(0.5)?

Any advice would be very highly appreciated.

Thanks very much.
Zhirong

2

Please have a look at the manual of the unstable version. That version provides the required posterior estimates of the DSGE-VAR (stored in oo_.dsge_var.posterior_mode). The code generating the DSGE-VAR IRFs can be seen in

PosteriorIRF_core1.m
3

Dear Johannes,

Thanks very much for your help. This has been extremely helpful!

Kind regards,
Zhirong

4

Dear Johannes,

I hope you are doing well.

I could not find the code used to generate the DSGE-VAR impulse response functions. Would it be possible for you to upload the link again?

Thank you very much for your help.

Best regards,

Aldo

5

is at Making sure you're not a bot!

6

Thanks a lot dear Johannes,

Best regards,

Aldo